To universal fanfare from the mainstream and Catholic media, Pope Francis has issued a long-awaited document, Amoris Laetitia, "the
Joy of Love," as his conclusion to the Catholic Church's two-year Synod
on the Family. But to this Catholic, the pope's supposedly reformist
document is a botch job.
For two years, bishops presented their respective cases
for two contradicting views of marriage, re-marriage, and the Church's
own sacraments. Pope Francis didn't choose between these two options. He
chose them both. The pope did not effect some grand synthesis. He
merely gave his imprimatur to the Church's own confused practice on
these matters and, more frighteningly, to its self-doubt.
